J. Riley Adams

The Long Arc of Transformation: Progress and Resistance in Human Society

By: J. Riley Adams

​

November 6, 2024

 

Throughout human history, societal transformation has followed a predictable yet complex pattern: a persistent tension between forces of progress and forces of preservation. This dynamic, while often frustrating to those working toward change, is not only natural but perhaps necessary for sustainable social evolution.

​

THE HERO'S JOURNEY OF SOCIETY

Joseph Campbell, in his exploration of the hero's journey, provides a powerful metaphor for societal transformation. "The cave you fear to enter holds the treasure you seek," he famously wrote. Similarly, societies must face their deepest fears and challenges to achieve meaningful progress. The resistance to change that we encounter is not unlike the threshold guardians in Campbell's monomyth—forces that appear antagonistic but serve to test the resolve and authenticity of the transformation being sought.

 

THE NATURAL RHYTHM OF CHANGE

Martin Luther King Jr.'s observation that "the arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends toward justice" speaks to the inevitability of progress, while acknowledging its non-linear nature.

 

This pattern manifests across various domains:

 

Environmental Progress

Rachel Carson's "Silent Spring" faced fierce opposition from chemical companies, yet it catalyzed the environmental movement and led to fundamental changes in how we approach environmental protection. Today's climate activists face similar resistance, yet steady progress continues in renewable energy adoption and environmental consciousness

 

Social Justice

The suffragette movement, civil rights movement, and LGBTQ+ rights movement all followed similar patterns: initial resistance, gradual acceptance, and eventual integration into societal norms. As Gloria Steinem noted, "The truth will set you free, but first it will piss you off."

​

UNDERSTANDING RESISTANCE TO CHANGE​

​

Resistance to transformation isn't merely obstinacy—it often stems from deeply human needs and fears:

​

1. Security: People naturally seek stability and predictability

2. Identity: Change can threaten established cultural and personal identities

3. Power: Existing power structures naturally resist redistribution

4. Economics: Transformation often threatens established economic interests

 

Margaret Mead's observation that we should "never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world" remains relevant, but must be balanced with the understanding that change takes time and persistence.

 

THE ROLE OF TENSION IN TRANSFORMATION​

​

The friction between progressive and conservative forces serves several vital functions:

​

• Quality Control: Opposition forces change advocates to refine and strengthen their arguments

• Integration: Resistance slows change to a pace that allows for societal absorption

• Synthesis: The dialogue between opposing forces often leads to more sustainable solutions

 

STRATEGIES FOR LONG-TERM CHANGE

 

Drawing from historical success stories, several key principles emerge for effective transformation:

 

Maintain Perspective

As Buckminster Fuller noted, "You never change things by fighting the existing reality. To change something, build a new model that makes the existing model obsolete."

​

Build Inclusive Coalitions

Success often comes from building bridges between different groups affected by the same issues, creating a broader base for change.

 

Focus on Systems

Individual battles matter less than systemic transformation. As Donella Meadows argued, changing the paradigm from which a system arises is the most powerful lever for transformation.

 

THE ROLE OF EACH GENERATION

Each generation plays its part in the longer arc of transformation. As Maya Angelou said, "Do the best you can until you know better. Then when you know better, do better."

 

This intergenerational approach to change recognizes that:

• Progress builds upon previous achievements

• Each generation brings fresh perspective and energy

• Different generations play different roles in the change process

 

CONCLUSION

​

The tension between progress and preservation is not a bug in the system of human society—it's a feature. It ensures that change, while inevitable, occurs at a pace that allows for integration and adaptation. For those working toward positive transformation, understanding this dynamic can provide both patience and persistence.

​

The key is to remain focused on the long arc of transformation while taking practical steps in the present. As anthropologist Mary Catherine Bateson observed, "We are not what we know but what we are willing to learn." This willingness to learn, to change, and to grow—while respecting the natural rhythm of societal transformation—is what ultimately moves humanity forward.

The resistance we face today is not unique to our time—it is part of the eternal dance of human progress. By understanding this pattern, we can work more effectively within it, maintaining our vision for the future while acknowledging the natural processes of social change.